Silenced from within: How Indonesian universities are retaliating against their own academics

By Rafiqa Qurrata A’yun

In April 2026, a private university in Indonesia dismissed a lecturer, Jane (a pseudonym), who had worked there for eleven years. The dismissal followed what her faculty called a disciplinary violation, a reason that is often far from objective. Indeed, most cases cannot be separated from the broader context of how daily reality pressures inside Indonesian universities.

Having completed her doctoral degree at a European university, Jane believes her experience abroad may benefit her home institution. In a faculty meeting, for example, she tried to propose assessing English language proficiency for lecturers about to teach “international classes,” a type of class that offers higher remuneration than regular classes, yet is not always staffed by lecturers with adequate language competence. Jane’s idea was immediately interrupted by her own colleague in that meeting, who said her manner was impolite.

Silenced from within

But perhaps the most “annoying” action for the faculty was that she filed a report about faculty colleagues who allegedly published in predatory journals to advance their careers. She blew the whistle on the evidence she found, which, obviously, is publicly accessible to the faculty and the vice chancellery (rektorat). She received no response, so in April 2024 she escalated the matter to the Ministry of Higher Education, Science and Technology’s whistleblowing system. When the faculty realised her moves, she started to experience bullying, delays in promotion, and not getting her rights as a lecturer.

The Jane case shows that deciding to act as a whistleblower about integrity violations (often driven by institutional pressures to compete for accreditation, rankings, and other global metrics) has left her career vulnerable. Reality did not match any scholarship script in which recipients like Jane were expected to bring about change when they returned to their home country. 

In another case, Cenuk Sayekti experienced retaliation that can take subtle forms in the everyday life of a lecturer at a public university in Indonesia. Cenuk has faced retaliation after testifying in a judicial review proceeding petitioned by the Indonesian Campus Workers Union (Serikat Pekerja Kampus or SPK), which advocated that lecturers’ base salaries be no lower than the regional minimum wage. Alongside her union involvement, she also took part in the campaign against militarism.  

She faced not only cyber harassment that discredited her, but also consequences in her work. She was assigned very few teaching hours and no supervision of student theses, leaving her with only a minimal allowance. This inequitable allocation of work, which affected her earnings, served as a tool of retaliation, preventing her from pursuing her academic activities freely.

Pattern of retaliation

The true stories of Jane and Cenuk are familiar across both public and private universities in Indonesia. While the law guarantees academic freedom, practice does not follow suit. Their cases are not the only ones SPK has handled. SPK has documented how retaliation silences internal criticism of academic integrity issues or the exploitation of work. Retaliation does not always end in career termination; it can be subtle and by omission, for example, by denying access to promotion or by not providing teaching hours needed to meet the minimum requirements for allowance. The pattern is consistent: speaking out about problems within your institution can result in the loss of some of the workplace rights to which lecturers are entitled. These may include a position they held, an allowance or remuneration they are entitled to, or other resources such as research and conference funding, which is disbursed to people selected often on non-merit-based grounds.

Such retaliation perhaps has less public attention compared to attacks on academic freedom in the form of direct threats, such as threats of a lawsuit or criminal charges, which are not uncommon in Indonesia. Previously, in 2021, a lecturer in Aceh, Saiful Mahdi, was jailed for defamation after he criticised the recruitment process in his faculty at Syiah Kuala University, a public university in the Aceh region. He was released after spending about a month in jail, following a clemency amnesty granted by President Joko Widodo after broad national and international pressure.

In 2025, two environmental experts from IPB University (formerly Bogor Agricultural Institute), Bambang Hero and Basuki Wasis, were sued by a palm oil company for their testimony in a corruption trial on the tin commodity. The Cibinong District Court, however, ruled that the lawsuit against them could not proceed because it constituted a Strategic Lawsuit Against Public Participation (SLAPP). Nevertheless, this illustrates the risk academics face when providing testimony.

While every case of attack on academic freedom has its own nuances, the backlash Jane and Cenuk experienced reflects broader issues in Indonesia’s higher education system. People like them face administrative challenges, often through unnoticed exclusion: reduced teaching hours, reduced allowances, or long delays in career promotion. To a great extent, this can lead to quiet firing when people decide to leave their jobs. This is where campaigns like #JanganJadiDosen (do not be a lecturer) have recently gained popularity. 

Internal retaliation is real and far-reaching, yet such cases often receive limited attention, even though they reflect a vulnerability that is, unfortunately, familiar among academics in Indonesia, particularly those without connections to university leaders and high government officials. It is a bitter truth that, in the daily life of academia in Indonesia, patronage connections work far more effectively for career paths than merit-based ones.

Executive control and patronising culture

In Indonesia, two predominant factors enable internal retaliation and affect not only academics in precarious contractual positions but also those with permanent status, as reflected in the cases of Jane and Cenuk.

First, the continued executive control over university administration. As public institutions, universities have long been under direct state control and political oversight and thus lack substantive autonomy. This is reflected in the ministry of education’s appointment of the rector (vice chancellor) and approval of professorships, with the minister politically appointed by the ruling power. As a result, academics often must cultivate patronage networks with ruling elites to secure leadership positions or academic promotions, at the direct expense of institutional autonomy and academic freedom. 

Furthermore, this politicised environment fosters predatory practices that erode academic integrity, including plagiarism, publication in predatory journals, “the sale” of academic titles, and fraudulent conferences. Rebuilding collegial trust is also challenging when campus leaders, who are also academics, seek political connections with elites who, in return, seek instant university credentials and status for their political career. In this setting, academic leaders tend to protect their own positions rather than challenging the system. Even if any reform is well planned, it will be rare and likely to face strong attacks from the status quo.

Second, the patronising culture of everyday academic life has left lecturers vulnerable, especially those without access to powerful, well-resourced patrons. These patrons, whether political elites, government officials, high-ranking university leaders, or other influential figures, often rely on academic institutions for public legitimacy and validation. Professorial levels, for example, are treated as hierarchically superior, and the academic community has exaggerated this superiority, making it prone to practices of work exploitation. Rather than operating on meritocracy, institutional decisions regarding careers and work distribution have tended to reflect personal preferences or likes and dislikes.

In the Jane case, for example, her institution has undermined her image by focusing on personality issues through narratives about attitude, since she was accused of impolite communication with more senior lecturers. The so-called attitude issue is often treated as the first thing to determine and, to a great extent, serves as a distraction from the more significant academic integrity, abuse, and exploitation issues at the university.

For a long time, universities in Indonesia have tended to prioritise individual comportment over actual capability and loyalty to patrons. Politeness seems more important than the courage to speak the truth, particularly when it means exposing the institution’s shortcomings. Challenging this status quo requires the collective strength of academia and other university workers, who together form the backbone of higher education. Rather than framing these struggles in moralistic terms, they must be confronted directly.  Otherwise, this vicious circle will allow other cases like those of Jane and Cenuk to continue or perhaps even worsen. 

About the author: Rafiqa Qurrata A’yun is the Head of the Department of Communication, Information and Cooperation at the Indonesian Campus Workers Union (Serikat Pekerja Kampus), and a 2025-2026 Mellon Scholars at Risk Academic Freedom Fellow

Share This